America is better and harder

*

The most famous athlete in America today may be Caitlin Clark, who plays basketball for the University of Iowa.

Two days ago, she made the front page of The Washington Post. You’ll be able to read the article here.

When I graduated high school in 1967, my female classmates had no organized sports teams.

I don’t recall ever thinking there was anything wrong with that.

What we didn’t see then that seems so obvious now is incredible.

I was born in 1949.

That America was a different country than the one I live in today.

Jackie Robinson became America’s most famous athlete two years before my birth.

Last year, Aliyah Boston, the Naismith Women’s College Basketball Player of the Year, led South Carolina to the national championship.

Fifty years after the first African American was admitted to The University of South Carolina.

Clark’s Iowa and Boston’s South Carolina meet tonight in a semifinal, with the winner advancing to the national championship game.

You can read here an article that compares these two phenomenal American athletes.

*

I grew up with the phrase America was the land of opportunity.

It was not a lie for me, a white, male, middle-class kid.

But it was for Caitlin Clarks and Aliyah Bostons of mine and previous generations.

For this story, I focused on one corner of American athletics.

The images of those included tell a story of how America has improved.

Truer to its ideals.

A story of progress.

Pick any facet of American society and conjure images of those on the inside.

Those images shout a similar story.

*

But nothing good comes without a cost.

When new people show up, they make new demands.

The best statement about this phenomenon comes from Jennifer Richeson, a Yale psychologist.

My lab is in an old engineering building and there’s exactly one women’s bathroom. No one noticed. And then slowly, Yale began adding women to the department, and they noticed it. They complained. Now there was friction. What had gone unnoticed by those in power in one era was unacceptable to those gaining power in another. When new people show up, they notice things and begin making demands.

From Ezra Klein’s Why We’re Polarized

The United States Women’s National Soccer Team has just won a demand for equal pay. You’ll be able to read about it here.

Alex Morgan, a captain on the 2015 & 2019 Women’s World Cup championship teams, said this about the settlement.

What we set out to do was to have acknowledgment of discrimination from U.S. Soccer and we received that through back pay in the settlement. We set out to have fair and equal treatment in working conditions, and we got that…And we set out to have equal pay moving forward for us and the men’s team through U.S. Soccer, and we achieved that.

Andrew Das, U.S. Soccer and Women’s Players Agree to settle equal pay lawsuit, Washington Post, May 18, 2022

But it looks years.

And struggle.

America was easy to run when only white males were in charge.

No one with power gives it up easily.

New voices with power make everything so much more complicated.

England’s George III would sympathize.

Reader Comments

  1. Laurie Fisher

    Loved this, Paul! “New people show up, notice things, begin making demands.” Reminds me of the movie Hidden Figures. African-American mathematicians working for NASA had to walk a long way to another building to use the only restroom available to them. They made demands and eventually got a closer restroom. Progress!

  2. Terri Doran

    Another thoughtful and thought-provoking essay, Paul. In retrospect it seems hard to believe that when I was growing up there were absolutely NO opportunities for women in athletics or so many other areas of life. We’ve come a long way but there is still more to go. My heart goes out to people of another skin color than white, immigrants, those with developmental disabilities, etc. as they too struggle to be recognized and respected.

Comments are closed.